|Julia Wallis Martin: The Bird Yard|
& Stoughton (Hardcover),
One November day, a wrecking crew discovers a body in a row house, not far from the aviary. The narrative jumps back to October, and the entire story unfolds. As of October, a boy had been missing for five years. Then another lad disappears a few hundred yards from where the first vanished.
The Greater Manchester Police, led by Detective Superintendent Parker, respond. The first missing child case, never solved, rankles Parker. He vows to find the second child. The investigation stalls until Parker meets Brogan Healey, a twelve-year-old boy fascinated by Roly's birds.
The Bird Yard suffers from "second book slump." Martin's first mystery, A Likeness in Stone, delved into each character's psychology and motives. Plot twists, all believable, surprised the reader. The perpetrator, when exposed, revealed an inhumanity without remorse.
In addition, the book fails the plausibility test on two important points. First, the missing boys and Brogan come from broken homes with uncaring or absent parents. Does Ms. Martin believe a child never disappears from a loving nuclear family? For example, after the first boy vanishes, his mother converts from slut to saint, finally holding a job. Parker notices "a total transformation" of her apartment, from slovenly to pristine. The conclusion? Bad mothers and fathers lose their children.
Second, Parker strong-arms Murray Hanson, a London psychologist specializing in "offender profiling," to work on the second case. Although U.S. authorities embrace this forensic technique, Parker distrusts it. Parker often dismisses Hanson's opinions! Once Hanson enters the narrative, Martin introduces an irrelevant, distracting sub-plot.
Now -- that haunted feeling. Finally, I realized what caused it. Forget the people! Martin fully depicts the birds -- features, actions, fears and mistreatment -- bonding me with them! They became the main characters, innocents condemned to death when the police destroy their refuge.
At least, The Bird Yard evokes sorrow for Roly's birds. This reviewer, not an Audubon aficionado, mourns the birds' fate. Whether or not you read The Bird Yard, visit your local bird sanctuary.
Lynn I. Miller
Click here to share your views.
I just read Lynn I. Miller's review of J. Wallis Martin's The Bird Yard. It wasn't very complimentary. Do I detect a little female jealousy here? Will Ms. Miller be revising her opinion now that Publishers Weekly voted The Bird Yard one of the best crime novels published in the US in 1999?